Posts Tagged ‘North American Class 1 railroads’

Mantle Ridge Disputes CSX News Release

February 18, 2017

Hedge fund Mantle Ridge took issue with some facts contained in a CSX news release issued earlier this week on the subject of E. Hunter Harrison becoming the railroad’s CEO.

CSX logo 3Mantle Ridge head Paul Hilal said he wrote to the CSX Board of Directors to take issue with the news release, in particular the size of the compensation package for Harrison and Milal’s demands for governance changes for the CSX board.

“We owe it to the shareholders to get a deal done promptly. Let’s do it,” Hilal wrote. “If you are willing, we are glad to meet in person and hammer this out this weekend, hopefully delivering good news to the shareholders early next week.”

In the meantime, Harrison told the Wall Street Journal that he was frustrated with what he described as “chest pounding” between his investment partner and CSX, which has resulted in a stalemate in the negotiations for him take over as CSX as its CEO.

The newspaper reported that CSX had offered the CEO post to Harrison, but that Hilal, a principle at Mantle Ridge, has refused to give in on compensation and governance demands. Hilal, who is representing Harrison, has conducted most of the discussions with CSX.

Mantle Ridge holds less than 5 percent of CSX stock but wants to name six directors to the railroad’s board of directors and reduce the number of directors to 12,

In the news release, CSX said it is reluctant to allow a shareholder with such a small share of its stock to dictate the composition of its board. CSX also has described the demands to give Harrison a $300 million compensation package as “extraordinary in scope.”

The Journal said that during a recent meeting with Mantle Ridge, some CSX shareholders objected to the number of seats on the board that Mantle Ridge wants.

Hilal reportedly said during the meeting he needs to control six seats so that Harrison “has control and can execute his plan.”

CSX reportedly is objecting to paying Harrison the $89 million he gave up by leaving early as Canadian Pacific’s CEO in return for receiving a limited waiver of a non-complete clause.

Hilal contends that the compensation deal that Mantle Ridge is seeking from CSX is $200 million and includes $120 million of stock options, about half of which are tied to “very real” performance measures.

Another sticking point is the 72-year-old Harrison’s refusal to agree to have a physical exam by an independent physician.

Harrison told the Journal he was willing to negotiate his pay with the CSX board,

In his letter, Hilal contended that Harrison wants $32 million per year over four years – or $128 million – of which $20 million per year is performance-based.

“His package is worth very little unless he performs spectacularly,” Hilal wrote. As for the changes on the CSX board, Hilal said he is only seeking a seat for himself.

Harrison would occupy another seat along with four other independent directors who would be agreed upon by CSX and Mantle Ridge

“Why are we asking that new directors be added? As we’ve discussed, precision scheduled railroading requires dramatic operational and cultural change,” Hilal wrote. “Change like that starts at the top, with significant new blood on the board not wed to the old ways or legacy decisions and with no ties to any previous strategy or anyone.”

CSX Said to be Talking With Harrison

January 31, 2017

The Wall Street Journal reported on Monday that CSX and E. Hunter Harrison are in negotiations about the railroad’s CEO position.

CSX logo 3Harrison has presented to CSX management his plans to revamp CSX. The former CEO of Canadian Pacific, Canadian National and Illinois Central, is teaming up with Paul Hilal of the Mantle Ridge hedge fund to seek a management shakeup at CSX.

Mantle Ridge was reported to be seeking three seats on the 12-seat CSX board of directors, a demand that may be a source of conflict the Journal reported.

News reports indicate that Harrison met with CSX officials last Friday in Atlanta.

If CSX, Harrison and Mantle Ridge are unable to reach an agreement, then the hedge fund has until Feb. 10 to nominate candidates to the CSX board. CSX usually holds its annual meeting in May.

It is not clear what plans that Harrison and Mantle Ridge have for revamping operations at
CSX.

In the past year, CSX management under current CEO Michael Ward has retooled rail operations. Among other steps, CSX has emphasized longer trains and focusing capital expenditures on core routes.

In 2015, Ward said he planned to remain the CSX CEO for three more years after Oscar Munoz, who was expected to replace Ward, left to head United Airlines.

While at CP last year, Harrison unsuccessfully sought a merger with Norfolk Southern.

Some analysts on Wall Street believe CSX will be receptive to having Harrison as CEO because of his experience in leading other class 1 railroads.

5 Class 1 RRs to Cut 2017 Capital Spending

January 28, 2017

Five of North America’s seven Class 1 railroads plan to spend less in 2017 on capital spending than they did last year.

train image2Norfolk Southern’s capital budget will remain static at $1.9 billion while at CSX capital spending will fall from $2.7 billion to $2.2 billion.

The NS budget includes $930 million for track maintenance, $290 million for locomotives, $240 million for positive train control, $170 million for facilities and terminals, $110 million for technology and similar initiatives, $80 million for infrastructure, and $50 million for freight cars.

The CSX budget figures include $307 million in payments for locomotives that were purchased under seller financing and delivered in 2015.

In 2017 equipment investments are significantly less due to the completion of locomotive purchases.

Canadian Pacific plans to spend C$1.25, an increase of 6 percent from the 2016 budget with around 70 percent of that earmarked for basic replacement and maintenance of way work

Union Pacific has cut its capital budget by 11 percent compared with 2016. The western freight hauler plans to spend $3.1 billion, compared with $3.5 billion last year.

BNSF is cutting capital spending by 13 percent from $3.9 billion to $3.4 billion, saying it has invested a lot of capital in network improvements and growth during the past several years.

At Canadian National, capital spending for 2017 has been set at C$2.9 billion of which C$1.6 billion is for for basic track infrastructure work.

Kansas City Southern has slashed capital spending by about $30 million and expects to spend between $550 million to $560 million in 2017.

CP Won’t Bar Harrison from Working for CSX

January 25, 2017

A regulatory filing made by Canadian Pacific with the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission shows where E. Hunter Harrison can and cannot work under the terms of his non-compete agreement with CP.

E. Hunter Harrison

E. Hunter Harrison

Harrison, who recently stepped down as CP’s CEO, cannot work for Canadian National, BNSF or Union Pacific. But he could work for CSX, Norfolk Southern or Kansas City Southern.

CP granted Harrison a limited waiver of the non-compete clause, which also included waiving a provision that Harrison is not permitted to solicit for employment at another company any CP employees above the level of manager.

Specifically, CP’s waiver makes an exception for the railroad’s chief of staff.

News reports have said that Harrison is teaming up with activist investor Paul Hilal of the firm Mantle Ridge to oust CSX CEO Michael Ward.

Some believe that Harrison would use being the head of CSX to lead a merger effort. Last year Harrison and CP unsuccessfully sought to merge with NS.

If Harrison does make a bid to become part the CSX CEO, he will have until Feb. 10 to do so under the terms of the CSX bylaws for nominating members of the board of directors and filing resolutions to be heard during the annual meeting, which is usually held in May.

CSX To Shut Down on Christmas Eve

December 20, 2016

CSX said this week that it will shut down operations on Christmas Eve and reopen on Dec. 26.

CSX logo 1In a customer service advisory, CSX said operations will cease at 3 p.m. on Dec. 24 and resume at 7 a.m. on Dec. 26.

That is similar to a shutdown announced last week by Norfolk Southern, which plans to shut down on Dec. 24 remain idle until Dec. 27. NS has said that it will “not accept trains at interchanges” during the days that it is closed.

Trains magazine observed that also other Class I and regional railroads are scaling back operations on non-essential route, none are planning complete shutdowns as are NS and CSX.

Amtrak and commuter trains that use CSX and NS are not expected to be adversely affected by the holiday service closures.

Class 1 RR Employment Fell in October

November 29, 2016

Employment at U.S. Class I Railroads fell 8.28 percent in October 2016 when compared to what it was in the same month a year earlier.

STBA report by the Surface Transportation Board found that the railroads employed 151,900 in October 2016, which was down 0.38 percent compared with September employment numbers.

All reported employment categories reflected workforce decreases in October when compared to the same month a year earlier and when compared to September 2016 employment.

CP’s Harrison Highest Paid Class 1 CEO in 2015

May 7, 2016

He may have lost out on becoming the CEO of Norfolk Southern, but E. Hunter Harrison has 15 million reasons to be happy with being the head of Canadian Pacific.

Trains magazine reported that Harrison is the highest paid CEO among North American Class I railroads.

In 2015, he took home $15.4 million in compensation (C$19.9 million). That was well above the $10 million made by Union Pacific CEO Lance Fritz.

E. Hunter Harrison

E. Hunter Harrison

Other CEO pay last year included: Michael Ward, CSX, $9.2 million; James Squires, NS, $7.9 million; David Starling, Kansas City Southern, $7.9 million; and Claude Mongeau, Canadian National, $7.7 million.

BNSF is a part of privately-owned Berkshire Hathaway and executive compensation figures are not publically available.

Not everyone at CP believes Harrison should be so well compensated. At last month’s CP annual meeting, stockholders rejected by 50.1 to 49.9 percent CP’s executive compensation package.

In response, the CP board of directors said it would take the non-binding resolution into account when setting the pay for executives this year.

However, Harrison and the CP board won re-election to their posts, receiving 96.6 percent of the votes cast.

In 2015, Harrison was paid a base salary of $2,803,522, stock awards of $4,749,089, options awards of $5,163,279, non-equity incentive plan compensation of $6,002,537, and other compensation of $1,184,026. All figures are in Canadian dollars.

Trains reported that Harrison’s base salary is high because he had to forfeit $1.5 million in annual CN pension payments in order to take the job at CP. Harrison was the CEO of CN before joining CP in June 2012.

In a proxy filing, CP asserted that by subtracting the pension makeup payments, Harrison’s base salary is $700,000, which the Calgary-based company said is “significantly below his prior salary at CN, industry norms, and CEO salaries in CP’s comparator group.”

The proxy filing justified Harrison’s pay package by saying that under his leadership CP has transformed from the industry’s worst financial performer to among its best.

“Although Mr. Harrison’s total compensation is much higher than his peers, the return to shareholders during his tenure is equally impressive,” CP said, adding that during Harrison’s tenure as CEO that CP added $14.2 billion in total additional shareholder value.

Fritz, who became CEO of UP in February 2015, earned a salary of $966,000, a bonus of $2 million, stock awards of $3,600,488, option awards of $2,400,008, change in pension value and deferred compensation earnings of $980,911, and other compensation of $139,220.

Ward of CSX had a base salary of $1.2 million, stock awards of $7,064,833, non-equity incentive plan compensation of $864,000, and other compensation of $80,728.

Squires took over as NS CEO on June 1, 2015, and was paid a base salary of $837,500, stock awards of $1,625,268, option awards of $4,375,050, a change in pension value and deferred compensation earnings of $1,036,596, and other compensation of $115,151.

Starling at KCS pulled down a base salary of $900,000, a bonus of $326,669, stock awards of $5,529,963, option awards of $551,195, non-equity incentive plan compensation of $468,000, and other compensation of $124,683.

CN’s Mongeau received a base salary of $1,075,000, an incentive bonus of $1,290,000, performance share units of $3,256,065, and stock options worth $2,144,000.